When purchasing a car, there is always a quandary between new and used cars. On one hand, it feels nice to hop into something completely unused, and the car’s maintenance and servicing are completely within your hands. From the moment you open the door, that new car smell hits you, and it’s a difficult sensation to ignore. Of course, there is also the second-hand route. Admittedly, this is more of a risk than buying a brand-new car, but when you weigh up what you can get for your money, the opportunities are exciting.
There are no options more philosophically opposed than a used Jaguar and a brand-new Toyota. With the latter being renowned for world-class reliability in even the used market, a brand-new Toyota is often the gold standard for picking a vehicle that is going to last. The ultimate sensible choice. Then on the other side of the universe, there is a second-hand Jaguar – fast, luxurious, exciting, and aspirational. There is no doubt that you get more for your money with a used luxury car, but is the thrill of owning a British brute really worth the world’s most sensible decision of buying a brand-new Toyota?
Jaguars: Modern Heritage Of Iconic Sports Cars
Plenty has been said about classic Jaguars like the E-type, but for most people, these legends simply aren’t affordable anymore. There is a lot to be said about Jaguar’s output since the 1996 XK8, which set the blueprint for modern Jaguar coupes. With a proprietary V8, which has been the go-to architecture ever since for the company’s performance beasts, the XK8’s powertrain and sleek looks brought Jaguar into the modern era. The Jaguar XKR supercharged would take the manufacturer into the 2000s as the flagship model and would be replaced by the new shape XK in 2006, which still very much feels like the definitive classic-meets-modern Jaguar fusion of the 21st century.
Some Of The Most Notable Jaguar Coupes
- The Jaguar XK120 and XK140 (1951 to 1961)
- The Jaguar E-Type (1961 to 1974)
- The Jaguar XJS (1975 to 1996)
- The Jaguar F-Type (2013 to 2024)
Want A Reliable Jaguar? These 10 Models Have Proven Themselves
Jaguars don’t have the best reputation for being reliable, but these 10 models buck the trend and have proven themselves as dependable companions.
The Jaguar F-Type Is Now Cheaper Than A Brand New Corolla
The Jaguar F-Type is already becoming a modern classic, despite feeling incredibly recent. It was a pivotal moment for Jaguar and one that would actually see the death of its traditional sports car lineup. As Jaguars move away from internal combustion sports cars and into the world of electrified ultra-luxury, the F-Type is the modern heartthrob that somehow feels closer to an E-Type in spirit than the company’s planned EVs. With a timeless design that still looks gorgeous today, the lightweight aluminum chassis, and the evocative V6 and V8 powertrains, you’d have a heart of stone to not desire the F-Type.
But for some, the head is a stronger entity than the heart. A five-year and 60,000-mile warranty on an already bulletproof Toyota may seem boring compared to the crackling exhaust of an F-Type, but under the pressure of life, a Corolla is king. With practicality, reliability, and efficiency being three of the most essential hallmarks of everyday commuting, it’s hard to ignore the financial logic of buying a Toyota. Even though the prices are similar, the Jaguar costs much more money to have simple maintenance done, and the chances of a huge repair bill coming your way are exponentially higher.
These Are The First 10 Production Cars In History With Factory Turbochargers
We may love a good turbo today, but they had to start somewhere – here are the first 10 production cars to boast a turbocharged engine under the hood.
The Cost Of A 2016 F-Type Vs. A Corolla In 2026
Realistically, for the same price as a mid-spec Corolla, you will be looking at an F-Type V6. But that is not to be scoffed at. Though the V8 is the one many people aspire to, the V6 still has a signature soundtrack, excellent performance, and more real-world usability. However, if you desperately want a V8, look more toward a 2014 model with higher mileage. This isn’t a practical decision, though, as we would recommend sticking to a lower mileage, slightly newer V6 F-Type with a more certain maintenance history for this budget.
The 2026 Toyota Corolla starts at $23,125 for the base gas-only LE and $24,975 for the base hybrid LE, and for that range, you can get a V6 F-type that has done around 50,000 to 70,000 miles. Examples that have around 100,000 miles sit around $20,000, but proceed with caution. Make sure to check the service history with an even finer-toothed comb on a car with higher mileage.
The Performance Of That Roaring V6 In The F-Type
The V6 engine is fantastic. So much of what makes it excellent comes down to that supercharger, which turns a smooth, grunting V6 into a rocket ship of instantaneous power and incredible throttle response, almost as if it’s a V8. With electronically controlled bypass valves that open under heavy acceleration, it’s clear Jaguar wanted this V6 to sound incredible, too. The result is a raspy symphony of pop and crackles, a truly addictive soundtrack for a V6.
2016 Jaguar F-Type Specifications
|
Powertrain |
3.0-liter supercharged 24V V6 |
|
Transmission |
8-speed ZF auto or 6-speed ZF manual |
|
Horsepower |
340 |
|
Torque |
332 lb-ft |
|
0-60 mph |
5.1 seconds |
The V6 models are also around 250 pounds lighter than the V8 F-Types, giving them a slightly more dynamic feel. Of course, there is nothing to actually match that V8 for outright grunt. With 200 extra horsepower and torque that can throw you forward effortlessly, that model is still the golden standard – but the V6 is surprisingly excellent too.
The Affordable Japanese Car That’s Perfect For A First-Time Buyer
Toyota’s popular compact sedan remains a first-timer’s dream.
Annual Costs Of Both Vehicles
The F-Type is undoubtedly a thirsty car, achieving 19 miles to the gallon compared to the Corolla’s 50 mpg on the hybrid variants. Because of this and the Jags’ need for premium fuel, based on 12,000 miles a year, the F-Type could cost up to $2,500 more on fuel. However, most people buying a 10-year-old F-Type aren’t going to be buying it for doing crazy mileage; it will more than likely be a weekend car or an occasional vehicle.
When you consider that full service on an F-Type could set you back a couple of thousand dollars, brakes costing around a thousand, and tires being more than double what you’d spend on a Corolla, the initial bargain bubble is burst. Then there is the uncertain nature of things going wrong and replacing components.
The Used Luxury Hybrid That Everyone’s Overlooking
The Volvo S90 PHEV is the luxury hybrid nobody’s bragging about. It is smooth, clever, quietly quick, and oddly satisfying once you live with it.
Buying An F-Type Preserves Jaguar’s Final Sports Hurrah
Despite all the reasons not to buy an F-Type, as discussed in the money it could cost you over the course of a few years, it’s still tempting. Part of that comes down to what the vehicle resembles. Up front, a large, supercharged engine, powered by the rear wheels. That, paired with a premium leather interior with a 380W sound system, analogue dials, and well-crafted buttons, makes the F-Type feel like a final stand for what Jaguar used to represent.
It’s not efficient, nor logical, and it’s the complete opposite of a 2026 Toyota Corolla. But if you want a vehicle that is frozen in time as the last of its type, has mesmerizing performance, and puts a smile on your face, then you can live with the deep pockets you’ll likely need to keep it on the road.